The UK government has announced it will review the country’s age of consent laws following the conviction of Russell Brand and calls from a survivor for legal changes to address power imbalances in relationships involving 16- and 17-year-olds.
Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden confirmed on Sunday that ministers are considering a staggered age of consent, which would make sexual relationships between adults and 16- or 17-year-olds illegal in certain circumstances. The current law allows adults of any age to legally have sex with 16- and 17-year-olds in England and Wales.
Louise Haigh, the de facto deputy prime minister, also stated that the government is examining whether to ban the use of non-disclosure agreements (NDAs) to silence victims of sexual abuse, particularly in cases involving powerful individuals.
Government Response to Public and Political Pressure
The potential policy shift comes amid heightened scrutiny of high-profile abuse cases, including Brand’s conviction on one count of rape and three sexual assaults, for which he was sentenced to 10.5 years in prison on Monday. Brand was 30 when he allegedly raped a 16-year-old girl, now identified as Mia Latter, who waived her anonymity to share her story.
McFadden, speaking on Sky News, acknowledged that the cases involving Brand and comedian David Walliams—who faces allegations of sexual assault when the accuser was 15—have prompted a re-evaluation of existing laws. He stated: “I think the whole country last week has been appalled by the abuse of power by powerful men. And a big age gap can be part of that, can be a factor on that.”
Haigh, in an interview with The Sunday Times, described Latter’s account as “heartbreaking” and emphasized the need to center survivor experiences in policy discussions. “It clearly would be a massive step to change the age of consent, but it deserves proper consideration and scrutiny,” she said. “I can absolutely understand why she is calling for it.”
Proposed Changes and Legal Context
The age of consent in the UK has been set at 16 since 1885, under the Criminal Law Amendment Act. Campaigners argue that the current law “legally allows adults to have sex with children” when the age gap is significant, despite the legal age of consent being 16.
Latter, who met Brand in Leicester Square when she was 16, has been a vocal advocate for reform. In an interview, she questioned why public focus often centers on the age gap rather than the broader issue of exploitation: “Why is that the thing that everybody collectively gets stuck on? I think we all sort of agree that adults shouldn't be allowed to have sexual relationships with children, with somebody under the age of 18.”
The government has not yet specified a proposed age threshold for the staggered consent rule or outlined a timeline for legislative changes. However, McFadden indicated that discussions are underway to address abuses of power, including potential reforms to NDAs, which have been criticized for silencing victims in cases involving high-profile figures.
Political and Public Reactions
The proposals have received mixed reactions from advocacy groups and legal experts. Some supporters argue that a staggered consent law would provide clearer protections for vulnerable teenagers, particularly in cases where there is a significant power imbalance between partners. Others caution that such changes could criminalize consensual relationships between peers close in age or create unintended legal complications.
Legal professionals have noted that defining an appropriate age threshold—such as prohibiting relationships where the adult is more than five or ten years older—would require careful drafting to avoid over-criminalization. Critics also point out that the current law already criminalizes sexual activity with children under 13 and includes provisions for abuse of trust, such as in teacher-student relationships.
Next Steps and Broader Implications
The government has not committed to a specific legislative timeline but has signaled that any changes would be subject to public consultation and parliamentary scrutiny. Haigh emphasized that survivor testimonies, such as Latter’s, will guide the process: “We need to listen to Mia and other victims like her who have been through these experiences, because it's really important that as lawmakers their experience is at the heart of what we consider.”
The potential reform also aligns with broader efforts to address sexual exploitation and abuse of power, including recent changes to NDAs in employment contracts to prevent their misuse in silencing victims of harassment or assault.
For now, the government’s review remains in its early stages, with further details expected in the coming months as discussions progress.